# Fixture: Primary Research — Weak human_oversight description → warn (primary mode never blocks)
# Expected validator result: exit 0, overall_decision = warn, user_action_required = true
# prisma_trAIce: null  (cross-field rule: primary_research → null)
# raise.mode: principles_only → roles NOT required, omitted entirely
# CA-4 does NOT fire: all pass principles (transparency, reproducibility, fit_for_purpose) have evidence.

mode: primary_research
stage: "4.5"
generated_at: "2026-04-20T09:30:00Z"

prisma_trAIce: null

raise:
  mode: principles_only
  principles:
    human_oversight: warn
    transparency: pass
    reproducibility: pass
    fit_for_purpose: pass
  principle_evidence:
    human_oversight:
      - "[weak evidence] Section 4: manuscript states 'the first author reviewed AI outputs' with no further detail on review protocol, criteria, or proportion of outputs checked."
    transparency:
      - "Methods 2.2: model name (claude-sonnet-4-6), API version, and prompt template included as supplementary material."
      - "Author contribution statement: AI use declared per journal policy."
    reproducibility:
      - "GitHub repository github.com/example/study2026: analysis scripts and prompts archived under MIT license."
      - "Methods 2.3: random seed fixed (42); environment pinned in requirements.txt."
    fit_for_purpose:
      - "Methods 1.3: AI assistance limited to literature synthesis; all statistical analyses performed with R 4.3 without AI involvement."
      - "Discussion 5.1: AI tool selection rationale provided; alternatives considered and scope limitations acknowledged."
  block_decision: warn

overall_decision: warn
user_action_required: true

upstream_sync_status: current
