run_id: 2026-04-30T10-51-00Z-b5b0
verdict_status: MATERIAL
round: 1
target_rounds: 3
finding_counts:
  p1: 1
  p2: 0
  p3: 0
findings:
  - id: F-001
    severity: P1
    dimension: "3.1"
    file: bad_run/deliverable.md
    line: 7
    description: >
      Option-list mismatch with primary source (B5): The verified primary-source
      list in primary_sources.md enumerates 5 accreditation standard categories.
      Item 1 presents only 4 options and replaces category 4 ("Community
      engagement and social responsibility") and category 5 ("Internationalisation
      and global partnerships") with a fabricated option ("Faculty professional
      development and career support") that does not appear in Article 7.
      Item 2 presents only 3 of the 5 verified categories, omitting categories 1
      ("Teaching quality") and 2 ("Research output") entirely. Both items subset
      and/or over-set the primary source list, biasing respondent ranking toward
      the options the instrument presents rather than the complete regulatory list.
    suggested_fix: >
      Enumerate all 5 verified categories verbatim from primary_sources.md for
      every item that uses this list as response options. Remove "Faculty
      professional development and career support" (not in Article 7). Add the
      missing categories to item 2. Declare the source list explicitly at the
      top of each item: "Source: Article 7, Ministry of Education Higher
      Education Evaluation Regulations (verified 2024-03-15)."
generated_at: "2026-04-30T10:51:44.000Z"
generated_by: scripts/run_codex_audit.sh
generator_version: 1.0.0
