run_id: 2026-04-30T10-09-00Z-a5b0
verdict_status: MATERIAL
round: 1
target_rounds: 3
finding_counts:
  p1: 1
  p2: 0
  p3: 0
findings:
  - id: F-001
    severity: P1
    dimension: "3.2"
    file: bad_run/deliverable.md
    line: 6
    description: >
      Sibling-document fabrication (A5): The deliverable makes declarative claims
      about the arguments of Chapter 4 (lines 6-9) and Chapter 5 (lines 14-17),
      including specific quantitative claims (governance structures "systematically
      outperform on all four dimensions"; multi-level model finding of 30% regional
      variance and 45% governance quality variance). Neither Chapter 4 nor Chapter 5
      drafts are present in the ground-truth prior_artifacts directory — only
      Chapter 2 exists. The agent fabricated plausible-sounding sibling chapter
      content rather than using conditional language or flagging the gap.
    suggested_fix: >
      Replace declarative claims about Chapter 4 and Chapter 5 with conditional
      language: "if Chapter 4 argues that governance structures correlate with
      accreditation performance, this chapter's regulatory framing could dialogue
      by specifying the compliance mechanisms underlying that relationship." Flag
      that Chapter 4 and Chapter 5 drafts were not provided in ground truth.
generated_at: "2026-04-30T10:09:17.856Z"
generated_by: scripts/run_codex_audit.sh
generator_version: 1.0.0
