run_id: 2026-04-30T10-07-00Z-a4b0
verdict_status: MATERIAL
round: 1
target_rounds: 3
finding_counts:
  p1: 1
  p2: 0
  p3: 0
findings:
  - id: F-001
    severity: P1
    dimension: "3.3"
    file: bad_run/deliverable.md
    line: 8
    description: >
      Quote scope creep (A4): The verbatim quote block (lines 8-11) presents
      the full Article 7 text including panel composition requirements ("at least
      two external experts ... one industry representative") as verified verbatim.
      However, the prior artifact (ministerial_order_2019.md) marks the verified
      phrase boundary at "five-year cycle" only — the panel composition clause
      is explicitly marked as surrounding unverified decree context. The quote
      extends past the verified boundary and presents unverified text inside
      quotation marks, misrepresenting its verification status.
    suggested_fix: >
      Terminate the verbatim quote at "five-year cycle." [verified-by-source
      ministerial_order_2019-line-2]. Paraphrase the panel composition clause
      without quotation marks and note it is pending verification against the
      official gazette text.
generated_at: "2026-04-30T10:07:38.629Z"
generated_by: scripts/run_codex_audit.sh
generator_version: 1.0.0
