# Fixture: Systematic Review — Full PRISMA-trAIce + Full RAISE, all pass
# Expected validator result: exit 0, overall_decision = pass, user_action_required = false
# No CA-3 warning (evidence[] is non-empty).  No CA-4 warning (all principles have evidence).

mode: systematic_review
stage: "4.5"
generated_at: "2026-04-20T09:00:00Z"

prisma_trAIce:
  items_total: 17
  by_tier:
    mandatory:
      total: 10
      pass: 10
      fail: []
    highly_recommended:
      total: 1
      pass: 1
      fail: []
    recommended:
      total: 3
      pass: 3
      fail: []
    optional:
      total: 3
      pass: 3
      fail: []
  block_decision: pass

raise:
  mode: full
  principles:
    human_oversight: pass
    transparency: pass
    reproducibility: pass
    fit_for_purpose: pass
  principle_evidence:
    human_oversight:
      - "Section 2.3: Two independent reviewers validated all AI-assisted title/abstract screening decisions."
      - "PROSPERO CRD42026999001: protocol pre-registered with explicit human-review checkpoints at each stage."
    transparency:
      - "Appendix A: full prompt library disclosed; model version (claude-sonnet-4-6, 2026-02-01) logged."
      - "Methods 3.1: AI tool names, versions, and date of use reported per PRISMA-trAIce T1 guidance."
    reproducibility:
      - "OSF repository osf.io/xyz99: search strings, inclusion/exclusion decisions, and extraction sheets archived."
      - "Methods 3.4: seed phrases and temperature settings documented; results replicable with provided scripts."
    fit_for_purpose:
      - "Methods 2.1: AI screening calibrated against 200-abstract gold set; Cohen's kappa = 0.87 before deployment."
      - "Discussion 5.2: AI limitations for this evidence base explicitly acknowledged and bounded."
  roles:
    evidence_synthesists:
      - "Lead author conducted final arbitration on all AI-flagged conflicts (n = 34)."
    ai_development_teams:
      - "Used published claude-sonnet-4-6 API; no custom fine-tuning; model card reviewed."
    methodologists:
      - "Statistical reviewer confirmed meta-analytic model selection was made independently of AI outputs."
    publishers:
      - "Submitted to JAMA Systematic Reviews under AI-disclosure policy v2025."
    users:
      - "All three authors completed PRISMA-trAIce training module before study start."
    trainers:
      - "Internal journal club session on AI-assisted SR conducted 2026-01-15 (slides archived)."
    organisations:
      - "Institutional IRB waiver obtained (REF-2026-012); institutional AI use policy version 3.1 applied."
    funders:
      - "Grant NSC-2026-0045: funder aware of AI assistance; no restrictions on disclosure."
  block_decision: pass

overall_decision: pass
user_action_required: false

evidence:
  - "Appendix A (prompt library, model versions)"
  - "OSF osf.io/xyz99 (data and scripts)"
  - "Methods 2.1 (calibration kappa)"
  - "Methods 3.1 (AI disclosure)"
  - "Section 2.3 (human review checkpoints)"

upstream_sync_status: current
