# Showcase: Full Academic Pipeline Output

Complete artifacts from a real 10-stage academic pipeline run, demonstrating the end-to-end quality assurance process.

**Paper**: *From Snapshots to Trajectories: How Agentic AI Will Redefine Student Learning Outcomes and Transform Student Success Measurement — Implications for Taiwan's Next Cycle of Institutional Accreditation*

## Paper Outputs

| File | Description |
|------|-------------|
| [full_paper_apa7.pdf](full_paper_apa7.pdf) | Final paper (English, APA 7.0 format) |
| [full_paper_zh_apa7.pdf](full_paper_zh_apa7.pdf) | Final paper (Chinese, APA 7.0 format) |

## Integrity Verification Reports

| File | Stage | Verdict |
|------|-------|---------|
| [integrity_report_stage2.5.pdf](integrity_report_stage2.5.pdf) | Pre-Review (Stage 2.5) | FAIL — found 15 fabricated refs + 3 statistical errors |
| [integrity_reverification_stage2.5.pdf](integrity_reverification_stage2.5.pdf) | Re-verification (Stage 2.5) | PASS — all 22 issues fixed |
| [integrity_report_stage4.5.pdf](integrity_report_stage4.5.pdf) | Post-Revision (Stage 4.5) | PASS — zero regressions, 3 new refs verified |
| [post_publication_audit_2026-03-09.pdf](post_publication_audit_2026-03-09.pdf) | Post-Publication Audit | 21/68 refs corrected — manual WebSearch stress test |

## Peer Review Reports

| File | Description |
|------|-------------|
| [stage3_review_report.pdf](stage3_review_report.pdf) | Round 1: EIC + 3 Reviewers + Devil's Advocate (5 independent reviews) |
| [stage3prime_rereview_report.pdf](stage3prime_rereview_report.pdf) | Re-review after Round 1 revisions |
| [stage3_review_report_r2.pdf](stage3_review_report_r2.pdf) | Round 2: Follow-up review |
| [response_to_reviewers_r2.pdf](response_to_reviewers_r2.pdf) | Author's point-by-point response to reviewers |

## Process Documentation

| File | Description |
|------|-------------|
| [paper_creation_process_en.pdf](paper_creation_process_en.pdf) | Pipeline process documentation (English) |
| [paper_creation_process_zh.pdf](paper_creation_process_zh.pdf) | Pipeline process documentation (Chinese) |

## Pipeline Stages Covered

```
Stage 1: Deep Research (13-agent research pipeline)
Stage 2: Paper Writing (12-agent writing pipeline)
Stage 2.5: Integrity Verification ← MANDATORY, caught 22 issues
Stage 3: Peer Review Round 1 (EIC + R1/R2/R3 + Devil's Advocate)
Stage 3': Author Revision + Re-review
Stage 3-R2: Peer Review Round 2
Stage 4: Final Revision
Stage 4.5: Final Integrity Verification ← MANDATORY, confirmed 0 regressions
Stage 5: Finalization (LaTeX → PDF, bilingual)
Stage 6: Process Summary
Post-Publication: Manual WebSearch audit of all 68 refs → 21 issues found & fixed
```

## Post-Publication Audit (2026-03-09)

After the pipeline completed, a manual WebSearch audit of all 68 references revealed 21 issues (31%) that survived three rounds of automated integrity checking. This stress test led to the integrity verification agent v2.0 overhaul (Anti-Hallucination Mandate, gray-zone elimination, known hallucination pattern library). See [post_publication_audit_2026-03-09.pdf](post_publication_audit_2026-03-09.pdf) for the full report.
